← All posts

How Enshittification Took the Wheel

Unrelated but my Private Equity partners had some notes on my monetization goals

It’s hard to pinpoint exactly when the internet stopped feeling like home.

MySpace

There was a time when having a MySpace profile meant something. Not just because it told people what music you liked, but because it reflected you. Neon text on black backgrounds, glittery cursors, autoplaying Evanescence tracks—your profile was a teenage bedroom in digital form. Messy? Yes. Loud? Absolutely. Yours? Unquestionably.

When someone messaged you, it was like receiving a letter, not a text. An actual message. You’d go back and forth like pen pals—not like now, where replies are expected instantly, lest you fall off the engagement treadmill and into the algorithmic abyss.

MySpace was chaotic. It was slow. And it was human.

Then came Facebook.


Facebook

At first, Facebook felt like a clean upgrade. Everyone’s page looked roughly the same. No more flame gifs. No more auto-playing Dashboard Confessional. Just white and blue.

You posted a photo, got a couple likes, maybe a wall post from a friend. You were connected, but not yet surveilled.

And then, slowly, the slope revealed itself. First came the News Feed—"to keep you up to date," they said. Then came ads. Then came targeted ads. Then came ads targeted at your emotional state at 2:00 a.m. based on your mouse movements, screen time, and subtle fluctuations in thumb pressure.

The feed wasn’t what you wanted to see. It became what they wanted you to see—which, let’s be honest, was just other people fighting and one aunt selling essential oils.


Instagram

Instagram started as a refuge for lost pictures of croissants. You’d snap a photo of your breakfast, slap on the Valencia filter, and move on with your day.

Then influencers happened. Then Reels. Then “shoppable posts.”

Now Instagram is a looping anxiety machine full of people pretending to live better lives than you, while trying to get you to buy a beige water bottle that’s part of their 17-piece minimalist “wellness drop.”

Scroll long enough, and the feed becomes indistinguishable from a QVC livestream, only everyone’s selling you on themselves. And they’re doing it in vertical video.


Discord

Discord was sweet because it wasn’t a platform. It was a place. Private. Purposeful. You made a server, added some friends, and talked about your weird niche interest without having to explain it to the entire internet.

But then came the bots. The integrations. The community discovery page. The crypto grift servers. The "partner programs."


AI, Algorithmic Slop, and the Infinite Scroll to Nowhere

The common thread? Platforms learned that you staying was more important than you enjoying yourself.

Every major app has become a Skinner box: you pull the lever (scroll), sometimes you get a hit (a meme, a baby goat, a half-true post about dopamine). But most of the time? You get digital sludge. Reposted TikToks. Reposted Tweets. Reposted Reddit screenshots. And a pop-up.

The content isn’t meant to inform or delight—it’s meant to keep you almost satisfied. Just enough to keep going. Never enough to leave.

And now with AI-generated content flooding feeds, it’s not just curated garbage. It’s machine-spun garbage, optimized for virality and SEO. Your favorite subreddit is now 60% LLM posts. That beautiful quote you liked on Instagram? A bot wrote it. That “travel influencer” reel you saw? Stock footage, fake voiceover, affiliate links.


What We Lost

We lost friction. And with it, we lost intimacy.

When the pace was slower, there was time for personality. For weirdness. For connection. Now, the only thing that scales is sameness. That’s the secret sauce of enshittification: make the platform just good enough to keep people using it, just bad enough to monetize them efficiently.

And once it’s too late—once we’re all too entrenched, too tired to move on—it really turns the screws.


Why It Happens (aka: Capitalism, But Make It Ergonomic)

There’s a lifecycle to online platforms, best described by author Cory Doctorow:

"First they’re good to users. Then they abuse users to please business customers. Then they abuse both to serve shareholders."

The process is gradual. You won't even notice the rot at first. But the algorithm does.

Enshittification isn't a bug. It's the business model.


In Closing (Please Allow Notifications)

We’ll keep scrolling. We'll keep posting. We'll keep pretending that the next platform will be different.

But somewhere deep inside, a glittery MySpace profile with a broken autoplay song still flickers in the dark—waiting for us to come home.

If only we could remember the password.


Want more content like this? Subscribe to our newsletter. Or don’t. That’s fine. We’ll just ask again in 5 seconds.

(And hey, while you’re here, check out our affiliate link for artisanal VPNs with integrated mindfulness tracking.)